Thursday, February 17, 2011

Questions for Dr. Payne


If you had the opportunity to visit with Dr. Payne over coffee, what are two open-ended questions you would likely ask her regarding the framework?

Q1:When it comes to education, as it relates to success, experience, and even access, so much pressure falls upon the teacher. But, what about the role of the parent? How much responsibility falls on the parent? Where do we draw the line, if ever? When does the problem stop being the “teacher’s problem and become the responsibility of the parent?


Q2:There is an ongoing debate as to whether all students should be held to the same standards. Do you feel that all students should be held to the same standards? And if your argument is yes, how do you suppose teachers in urban schools can actually help students meet the standards? If we know the middleclass point of view and idea of the world is different from that of poor students….then why should the test be the same?

Impact on Professional Practice



What are some things that you will implement (or have already implemented) and/or do differently regarding your interactions with children and/or adults resulting from your understandings of Payne's framework?
I have always believed that an education should serve as a tool/resource for children. Students should see an education as the key to success, a tool to help them rise above their circumstances, and/or the first step toward reaching their dreams. For poor students, selling drugs and other illegal and immoral activities often seem like the answer because they offer immediate results. It is much easier to sell drugs at the age of thirteen in order to help your family NOW than it is to wait until you have finished college nine of ten years LATER. An education is the key to getting out of, and staying out of, generational poverty. Individuals leave poverty for one of four reasons: a goal or vision of something they want to be or have; a situation that is so painful that anything would be better; someone who sponsors the, (i.e. educator, or spouse or mentor or role model who shows them a different way or convinces then that they can live differently); or a specific talent or ability that provides and opportunity for them (Payne, 2005, p. 61). For poor students, their educational experiences should provide them with self-empowerment, self-efficacy, and self-esteem. Teacher leaders should work using an “Empowerment Through Education” model. Successful administrators should support and lead teachers to follow an instructional model that encourages students to grow in every way. The way in which they see the world and their ability to impact the world should evolve.



Reference

Payne, R.K. (2005). A framework for understanding poverty. (4th ed.) The Highlands, TX: aha! Process, Inc.

Key Understandings

As a teacher leader, what are three key understandings you learned from the Payne text that you would deem appropriate for sharing with a colleague, administrator, and/or parent? Describe why these understandings were selected.

There are three key understandings that teacher leaders should understand:
1: We are trained from a middle-class point of view. Therefore, we must take into consideration, how the lower-class and upper-class points of view will offer different beliefs and practices.
2. Teachers have the opportunity to offer resources that federal funding could never provide i.e. the impact of being a good role model.
3. Teachers should try to see the world from their students’ eyes.

Although students are required to complete standardized examinations, our approach to students should not be standardized; in other words, not all students are the same. This may seem cliché and quite self-evident, however, in the field of education, teachers are often to trained to teach the prototype. Once in reality, when the students do not fit this particular mold, teachers are often in distress over how to approach the less than ideal student. During most teacher training programs, potential candidates are given a plethora of resources and information, but, more than likely they have not learned how the middle class methods of teaching do not apply to poor students or ESL students. Teachers should have a thorough understanding and cultural awareness of the current situation of their students. For example, if Michael is currently struggling with turning in his homework assignments, or even coming to school prepared with pencils and paper, a call home may seem like the solution. One call home, and the next day, he comes to class with all of his school supplies and missed assignments in his hand. Of course this may work in the middle –class home, but for a poor student, the phone might be disconnected, they might not be able to afford pencil and paper, or they may be the acting parent, raising their younger siblings. This is just one example of why teachers should be trained in understanding the varying points of view among the poor, middle, and upper-class. Resources of students and adults should be analyzed before dispensing advice or seeking solutions to the situation. What may seem to be very workable suggestions from a middle-class point of view may be virtually impossible given the resources available to those in poverty (Payne, 2005, p.25)

As a teacher in low-income communities, I have found that there is a lot of frustration among teachers; some feel powerless. There are not enough books, the classes are overcrowded, teachers have to buy the pencils and paper for their students, reading proficiency is well below grade level, and behavior management issues are just some of the concerns in the urban school. Constantly looking for funding to tackle some of these issues can be a major hurdle for educators. However, teachers still have the ability to inspire and implement change regardless of the economical resources made avail to them. “Educators have tremendous opportunities to influence some of the nonfinancial resources that make such a difference in students’ lives. For example, it cost nothing to be an appropriate role model” (Payne, 2005, p. 25). Teachers have the opportunity to make a significant impact on the lives of so many children. If we focus upon the gifts and talents of our students, we can help them to evolve. Acting as a support system, mentor, and/or coach, will help us to inspire our students to follow their dreams. If we are positive role models, we can be an alternative to the mainstream, negative images that are portrayed in the larger society. I am not saying that you are a bad teacher if your students still do drugs, because ultimately the choice is theirs; but, there is so much more to gain than there is to lose if we just try to reach our students in some way. And because our students see us every day, we have infinite chances to help better the lives of our students.

Leaders in the field of education should try to see the world from their students’ eyes. One of the biggest differences among the economic classes is how “the world” is defined for them. A child’s view of the world from a middle-class, two-income, household where both parents have advanced degrees will different drastically from the view of a child who is the youngest of four children, where the mother is single, unemployed, and without a high school diploma. This is not to say that all middle-income and low-income households fit this stereotype, however, I want to bring to your attention that there are differences, and these differences are very important. Many of the attitudes that students and parents bring with them are an integral part of their culture ad belief systems (Payne,2005, p. 45). The culture of poverty and the culture of privilege both create the practices, beliefs, and norms that students follow. They shape their world and their views of the larger society.

Reference

Payne, R.K. (2005). A framework for understanding poverty. (4th ed.) The Highlands, TX: aha! Process, Inc.

Thursday, January 6, 2011

Thinking OUTSIDE the box

Every truth has four corners: as a teacher, I give you one corner, and it is for you to find the other three. - Confucius